When planning accessible entrances for homes, businesses, or public spaces, two of the most popular accessibility solutions are wheelchair ramps and vertical platform lifts (also known as porch lifts). Both are effective at improving mobility and meeting ADA guidelines, but which is the better option depends on your specific needs, budget, and space.
Wheelchair Ramp vs. Vertical Platform Lift: What’s the Difference?
Wheelchair Ramp (Aluminium Ramp)
A wheelchair ramp—especially a durable aluminium ramp—is a sloped surface that allows individuals in wheelchairs or with limited mobility to enter and exit buildings without steps. Ramps are:
- Simple and cost-effective
- Permanent or modular (portable)
- Low maintenance
- Designed to meet ADA guidelines, an aluminum wheelchair ramp must be in 1:12 ratio, which means that for every inch of rise, a foot of ramp is required.
However, for higher rises (over 30 inches), ramps can become very long and require significant space, making them impractical in some settings.
Vertical Platform Lift (Platform Lift / Porch Lift)
A vertical platform lift is a mechanical device that raises or lowers a person in a wheelchair from one level to another—like a small elevator. Also called a porch lift, it’s ideal for areas where space is limited. Key benefits include:
- Space-saving design
- Suitable for heights 2–6 feet or more
- Smooth, powered operation
- Meets ADA accessibility standards when properly installed
However, platform lifts are generally more expensive and require regular maintenance and electrical components.
Which is Better for You?
| Factor | Wheelchair Ramp | Vertical Platform Lift |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Lower upfront cost | Higher initial investment |
| Space | Requires more space | Space-efficient |
| Maintenance | Minimal | Requires routine maintenance |
| Rise Height | Best for low rises | Ideal for higher rises |
| Weather Resistance | Excellent with aluminium ramps | May require enclosure in harsh climates |
| Installation Time | Quick and easy | Requires professional setup |
Ageing in Place & Long-Term Accessibility
For those planning on ageing in place, both solutions offer valuable independence. A modular aluminium ramp might be preferable for temporary use or gradual slope requirements, while a platform lift provides long-term comfort and is especially beneficial for users with limited strength or balance.
Cairo Contracting specializes in offering the best custom-made solutions to balance cost, comfort & convenience coupled with long-term usability goals. Whether you choose an aluminium ramp or a vertical platform lift, we ensure ADA compliance, durability, and peace of mind.
Need help deciding? Contact Cairo Contracting today for a free consultation!
